Why Do So Many Merchants Have Their Heads Up Their Arses?

It has transpired (correct me if I'm wrong!) that Woolworths have a closed brand bidding "group" of one!! How many bloody times do seasoned affiliates have to tell merchants that this is stupidity of the highest order?!!?!
There have been so many blog posts about this that it unbelievable that people are ignoring this sage advice and instead being exceptionally lazy had preferring the easy option of placing their heads up their arses:
- Get Rich Quick by Selling br$and to the Arabs for £75m
- BBG’s (Brand Bidding Groups) - Do You Take the Red Pill or The Blue Pill?
- Another Look At Brand Name Bidding
- The Economics of 0% Commissions, Brand Bidding And The Long Tail
- Cookies.. and a can of worms
- De-Duping and brand name bidding - part 2 of 2
- Woolworths - Opportunistic closed bidding group on brand just before Christmas
I'm just about to buy some shares in Woolworths Group PLC so I can attend their AGM and raise the question of the probable million or so they are wasting. It is no wonder they made a reported loss of £40.9 million in the half ear to 4 August 2007 if they operate their business without a keen eye on the bottom line and their marketing costs which totalled £264.6m (including selling costs).
With negative cash flow of £82.8m over the same period surely
they have to cut out as much unnecessary costs as possible?
I wonder how much their £8.5 million
overdraft they had on 4th August 2007 has grown because of their naive brand bidding policy?
They should NOT be using the affiliate marketing channel and its cookies to manage its online brand management campaign. They should be paying their Search Marketing Agency a retainer to look after it and cut the associated costs by at least 95% and not let one lucky affilaite walk away with the profits!
![]() |
3 Comments:
My understanding (I may be wrong) is that there is one affiliate who controls all the direct PPC, not just the brand.
I have just spent this weekend's beer money in the swear box!
I'll have to make do with a "FFS"!
Hi Lee,
Sorry been busy and missed this original thread. firstly I have to say that in general I agree with most affiliates feelings about closed brand bidding groups. However in the instance of Woolworths, the issue is slightly different, as Dave McFarlane mentions they have one PPC affiliate who works in the space.
To shed more light on this, Woolworths were concerned with the value of their 3rd party search and the volumes it was driving. They wanted to trial a PPC affiliate to measure comparable performance based against their own fixed ROI targets. Obviously Brand is easy and lucrative so commissions are vastly scaled back for brand related keywords. This partnership only exists so long as the merchant drives significant volumes from generic search terms and we run this through a seperate affiliate account so we have visibility on all the incremental elements to confirm no brand overlap. The campaign has had to be flexible and run only pre christmas and then again in March which has allowed the affiliate to prove the value.
This has however highlighted another concern raised by affiliates regarding brand affiliate links 'hijacking' returning affiliate traffic.
Woolworths did previously de-duplicate traffic against their own paid search, however we have been working together on a permanent solution to address this concern going forward. I'm pleased to say that we are 99% of the way there and in essence the brand affiliate link will not overwrite existing affiliate cookies. We will be writing about this on the forum in more detail in due course and this will form the network standard for any merchant programme that chooses to use affiliates for controlled PPC in the same way.
I'm hoping this explanation gives a clearer picture behind Woolworths and AW's thinking and also gives you the scoop on what we are doing to address the returning customer issue.
Kind Regards
Mark
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
Home:- Home
- RSS Feed
- Miss-Spells Tool
- 0 To 4,000 Visits A Day In Ten Weeks Using Blogging
- The 10 Affects Of Google's Trademark Policy Changes For Affiliates
- So Who Is MyVoucherCodes' Mark Pearson
- Twitter For Affiliate Marketing? Like Shooting Fish In A Barrel
- Top 10 Tools To Improve Affiliate Productivity
- Industry Greats - An Interview With Joe Connor
- Had Enough Of Crappy Link Building Emails
- So What Actually Is Wrong With Some Voucher Code Sites? Case In Point
- Don't Believe The Hype - All That Glitters May Not Be Gold
- Look To The Long Tail For Affiliate Gold
- How Should You Select Merchants To Promote? Part 1: Networks
- Has Seth Godin's Meatball Sundae Gone Off?
- Affiliates: What Has Google Ever Done For Us?
- Don't Do Paid Posts - I Told Ya So!
- My Christmas Winners at Affiliate Window
- No I Won't Sell Links, Sponsored Reviews Or Pay Per Post
- What Will Affiliate Marketing Be Like In 5 Years?
- The End Of Blogging Is Nigh
- Google Analytics Please Give Me For Christmas
- Another Look At Brand Name Bidding
- What Do You Need To Be a Successful Affiliate? The Ten Traits
- 10 Top Tips: Successful Affiliate Marketing During a Recession
- Why I Effectively Left Affiliate Marketing
- And Why I'm Back
- Complete Rubbish About Affiliate Marketing
- All Those Social Media Knockers: Start Listening
- The Great Big Social Land Grab - Call it Bubble 2.0
- Where ASOS Get's Its Traffic From
- SEO Ranking Factors
- Google to Hit "Hidden Links" Sites Harder
- Who Said Doorways & Hidden Link Spam Are Dead?
- Nick Robinson - ASOS Numpty?
- What Can You Learn From The Affiliate Marketing Leaders?
- Down to the Social - Twitter
- Dissecting Affiliate Marketing
- Via Email
- MSN - myname@hotmail.com
- Affiliate Marketing
- Brand Name Bidding
- SEO
- Social Media
- UK Affiliate Networks
- Altogether Digital
- dgm
- Webgains
- Nice New Feature From Google - Domain Recommendations
- Happy Happy Affiliate Talk, We're Talking Happy Af...
- Yahoo! Buzz And The Supposed Death Of Social Media
- Thanks Affiliate Window!
- I Love Trusting / Responsive Clients
- Has Seth Godin's Meatball Sundae Gone Off?
- February 2008 Archive
- At Christmas 'Delivery' Should Be A Key SEO Target
- 5 Minute Blogger Tip: Labels & Duplication
- Interview With James Little
- HallNet Ltd
- Hot in 2007
- Shiply
- Hot in 2009
- Hot in 2008
- SEO Warrington
- Get Visible Blogs (Out of date)

Most Popular Posts:
Twitter Updates:
follow me on Twitter
Contact Me
Lee's Views On:
Meet The Networks:
Previous Posts
Social Marketing Stuff
Related Sites
Another Affiliate Marketing Blog
2008 Posts
Jul / Aug / Sept / Oct / Nov / Dec
Jan / Feb / Mar / Apr / May / Jun
2007 Posts
Jul / Aug / Sept / Oct / Nov / Dec
Jan / Feb / Mar / Apr / May / Jun